Reaching Out to College Coaches

Following Up Without Being Annoying

One of the most challenging aspects of recruiting communication is knowing how and when to follow up with coaches. Families worry about being too pushy, but also fear being forgotten. The key is finding the right balance between staying on a coach's radar and respecting their time and communication preferences.

Understanding Coach Communication Styles

High-Communication Coaches

How they operate:

• Respond quickly to messages
• Initiate regular contact
• Provide detailed feedback
• Maintain active text/call relationships

Your approach:

• Match their communication frequency
• Be responsive to their outreach
• Provide regular updates as requested
• Maintain professional but friendly tone

Low-Communication Coaches

How they operate:

• Respond infrequently to messages
• Prefer email over phone/text
• Focus on key recruiting periods
• Communicate when they have something specific to discuss

Your approach:

• Send less frequent, more substantial updates
• Don't expect immediate responses
• Focus on quality over quantity
• Respect their preferred communication method

Ditch the Spreadsheet. Own Your Recruiting Journey.

VarsityBio gives athletes a professional profile and tools to manage outreach like a pro.

Get Started →

Variable Communication Coaches

How they operate:

• Communication intensity varies by recruiting cycle
• More active during their sport's season
• Respond based on current priorities
• May go silent during busy periods

Your approach:

• Adjust frequency based on their recent responsiveness
• Understand seasonal communication patterns
• Be patient during busy periods
• Continue consistent updates regardless of response frequency

Appropriate Follow-Up Timelines

Initial Contact Follow-Up

After first email:

• Wait 2-3 weeks before following up
• Reference your original message
• Add new information or updates
• Keep it brief and professional

After Coach Response

If they replied positively:

• Follow up within 1-2 weeks with requested information
• Maintain the communication rhythm they establish
• Provide updates as they occur
• Respect their preferred communication timeline

If they replied neutrally:

• Wait 3-4 weeks before next contact
• Focus on significant updates only
• Reduce communication frequency
• Continue professional relationship building

Seasonal Follow-Up Guidelines

In-season (your sport):

• Weekly updates acceptable if they've shown interest
• Game results, performance highlights
• Schedule updates for when they can watch
• Brief, focused messages

Off-season:

• Monthly updates appropriate
• Focus on training, academics, achievements
• Longer-form updates with more substance
• Include off-season competition results

Dead periods (NCAA):

• No direct coach contact allowed
• Send information through compliance office
• Continue relationship building when periods end
• Use time for academic and athletic development

Types of Effective Follow-Up

Performance Updates

What to include:

• Recent game statistics or achievements
• Competition results or rankings
• Athletic milestones or improvements
• Team accomplishments or championships

Example: "Coach Smith, I wanted to update you on our recent tournament results. We won the regional championship, and I had 15 kills and 3 blocks in the final match. Our team will be competing in the state tournament next week. I'll send you the bracket and schedule in case you're able to attend."

Academic Updates

What to include:

• GPA improvements or maintenance
• Test score improvements
• Academic awards or recognition
• Course scheduling relevant to college major

Example: "Coach Johnson, I wanted to share that I received my SAT scores back and improved from 1240 to 1340. I'm also maintaining a 3.8 GPA while taking 4 AP courses this semester. I know academics are important to your program, so I wanted to keep you updated on my progress."

Schedule Updates

What to include:

• Upcoming games or competitions
• Tournament schedules
• Camp or showcase participation
• Changes to competition schedule

Example: "Coach Davis, our playoff schedule has been finalized. We'll be playing in the regional semifinals on Friday at 7pm at Central High School. I know you mentioned interest in watching me play, so I wanted to give you advance notice of the date and location."

Recruiting Updates

What to include:

• Other official visits scheduled
• Commitment timeline updates
• Interest level in their program
• Questions about their program

Example: "Coach Williams, I wanted to update you on my recruiting timeline. I'm planning to make my college decision by early March. Your program remains one of my top choices, and I'm hoping to schedule an official visit in February. Are there any upcoming dates that would work well for a visit?"

What NOT to Include in Follow-Ups

Avoid These Topics

Pressure tactics:

• "I need to hear from you soon"
• "Other coaches are calling me daily"
• "If you don't respond, I'll assume you're not interested"

Irrelevant information:

• Personal problems or family issues
• Complaints about current coaches or teammates
• Negative comments about other programs
• Overly personal information

Excessive detail:

• Play-by-play game descriptions
• Every practice or training session
• Minor achievements or statistics
• Daily life updates

Communication Mistakes

Too frequent:

• Daily or every-other-day messages
• Multiple messages before receiving response
• Calling repeatedly without response
• Sending same information multiple times

Too demanding:

• Requesting immediate responses
• Asking for specific timelines
• Demanding evaluation feedback
• Insisting on phone calls or meetings

Reading Coach Response Patterns

Positive Engagement Signs

Communication indicators:

• Responds within reasonable timeframe
• Asks follow-up questions
• Provides specific feedback
• Initiates contact occasionally
• References your updates in conversations

What this means:

• Continue current communication frequency
• Maintain quality of updates
• Be responsive to their requests
• Consider increasing slightly if they're engaging more

Declining Interest Signs

Communication indicators:

• Response time increases significantly
• Shorter, less detailed responses
• Generic responses that could apply to anyone
• No follow-up questions
• Stops initiating contact

What this means:

• Reduce communication frequency
• Focus on significant updates only
• Don't increase pressure or frequency
• Consider focusing energy on more responsive programs

Neutral Engagement Signs

Communication indicators:

• Consistent but infrequent responses
• Professional but not personal tone
• Responds to direct questions only
• Updates you on program changes
• Maintains relationship but doesn't advance it

What this means:

• Maintain current communication level
• Focus on quality over quantity
• Be patient with relationship development
• Continue professional updates

Strategic Follow-Up Timing

Best Times to Follow Up

After significant achievements:

• Championship wins or tournament success
• Personal record achievements
• Academic improvements
• Award recognition

During recruiting windows:

• Before official visit seasons
• When coaches are actively evaluating
• During your sport's peak season
• Before commitment decision periods

Program-specific timing:

• After their season ends (coaches have more time)
• Before their recruiting camp dates
• When they announce recruiting news
• After coaching staff changes

Times to Avoid Follow-Up

During their competitive season:

• Week of big games or tournaments
• During conference championship periods
• Immediately after losses
• During coaching staff travel

Personal timing:

• Holidays and family time
• Dead periods when they can't respond
• When they've specifically requested space
• During known stressful periods (finals, etc.)

Sample Follow-Up Messages

Performance Update

Subject: Tournament Results - [Your Name]

Coach Martinez,

I hope your season is going well. I wanted to update you on our recent performance at the state tournament. We finished 2nd overall, and I placed 1st in my weight class with a 4-0 record.

My current season record is now 28-3, and I've improved my takedown percentage to 85%. We have one more tournament before the season ends - the regional championships on February 15th.

I'll continue to keep you updated on my progress. Thank you for your continued interest in my development.

Best regards,
[Your Name]

Academic Update

Subject: Academic Update - [Your Name]

Coach Thompson,

I wanted to share some good news about my academic progress. I just received my semester grades and maintained a 3.9 GPA while taking 5 honors courses. I also retook the ACT and improved my score to a 29.

I know your program emphasizes academic excellence, so I wanted to keep you updated on my commitment to performing well in the classroom as well as on the field.

I look forward to hearing from you when your schedule allows.

Best regards,
[Your Name]

Schedule Update

Subject: Upcoming Games - [Your Name]

Coach Robinson,

I hope you're having a great off-season. I wanted to give you advance notice that our playoff schedule has been released. We'll be playing in the regional semi-finals on March 8th at 7:00 PM at Valley High School.

I know you mentioned interest in watching me play, so I wanted to provide the details early in case you're able to attend. I'll send you the game location and parking information closer to the date.

Thank you for your continued interest in my recruitment.

Best regards,
[Your Name]

Managing Multiple Coach Relationships

Organization Systems

Tracking spreadsheet:

• Coach contact information
• Last contact date
• Response patterns
• Preferred communication method
• Key information to remember

Communication calendar:

• Scheduled follow-up dates
• Important dates for each program
• Seasonal communication adjustments
• Deadline reminders

Consistency Across Programs

Maintain standards:

• Professional tone with all coaches
• Consistent quality of updates
• Similar information sharing
• Reliable communication timing

Avoid comparisons:

• Don't mention other programs negatively
• Don't create artificial urgency
• Don't share confidential information from other programs
• Don't play coaches against each other

When to Stop Following Up

Clear Disinterest Signals

Stop following up if:

• No response to multiple attempts over months
• Direct statement that they're not interested
• Requests to stop communication
• Program needs change and you no longer fit

Relationship Preservation

How to stop gracefully:

• Send final professional message
• Thank them for their time and consideration
• Leave door open for future contact
• Maintain positive relationship for potential future opportunities

Building Long-Term Relationships

Beyond Recruiting

Maintain connections:

• Update coaches on college choice
• Share college athletic achievements
• Thank them for their role in your development
• Maintain professional network for future opportunities

References and Recommendations

Coaches can provide:

• Letters of recommendation for jobs
• Professional references
• Networking opportunities
• Mentorship and career guidance

The Bottom Line

Effective follow-up communication is about building relationships, not just staying visible. The key is providing value through your updates while respecting coaches' time and communication preferences.

Smart follow-up strategy:

• Match the coach's communication style and frequency
• Focus on quality updates over quantity of messages
• Respect their response patterns and preferences
• Maintain professionalism while building personal connections
• Know when to adjust or stop communication

Remember: The goal of follow-up is to build a relationship that benefits both you and the coach. Focus on being helpful, professional, and authentic rather than just trying to stay on their radar.

For guidance on what to say once coaches respond, see our article on What to Do After a Coach Replies.